Case No. 004 · AI Models
Gemini 4 Hydrogen vs Argon
Google launched Gemini 4 Hydrogen on November 12, 2026 — its fast, cheap everyday model — and it immediately outscored the flagship Google launched four weeks earlier. On the Artificial Analysis Intelligence Index, Hydrogen scores 51 at its default high setting and 54 at its new xhigh setting, against 50 for Gemini 4 Argon. So is Argon already obsolete?
The contenders
Gemini 4 Hydrogen
$1.50 in / $7.50 out per million tokens flat across the full 1M-token context window
For
- Outscores Argon on the Intelligence Index — 51 at high, 54 at xhigh, against 50
- Fastest task times in its class in Artificial Analysis's independent runs — about 6 minutes and $1.87 per task at high
- Free in Search, the Gemini app and AI Studio
Against
- A short-term release carrying a minimum 45-day retirement notice
- Gemini 4 Carbon, at 59, still scores above it
- Most launch benchmarks have not yet been independently replicated
Gemini 4 Argon
$2 in / $10 out per million tokens doubles to $4/$20 on December 1
For
- Built for the hardest, longest-horizon reasoning
- A frontier model with a normal lifecycle — no 45-day fuse
Against
- Outscored by the cheap model on the headline index
- Costs more today, and doubles in price on December 1
- Paid access only
The scorecard
| Criterion | Result | On the record |
|---|---|---|
| Intelligence | Hydrogen | Hydrogen 51 high, 54 xhigh — Argon 50 — Carbon 59 |
| Speed | Hydrogen | Fastest task times in its class — AA independent runs |
| Price | Hydrogen | Hydrogen 1.50 and 7.50 — Argon doubles on Dec 1 |
| Access | Hydrogen | Free in Search, the Gemini app and AI Studio |
| Staying power | Argon | Hydrogen carries a 45-day retirement notice |
Every line on this board is taken from the video, where its source is named on screen. The full reasoning is in the video.
Switch to Hydrogen for everyday work — Argon only for the hardest, longest jobs
If you use the Gemini app or Search, you have already switched. If you build with the API, Hydrogen at its default high setting should be your new starting point: frontier-adjacent intelligence, the fastest task times in its class, a free tier to test on, and a price that undercuts Argon today and crushes it from December 1. Argon is not quite obsolete — it still has a job: the hardest, longest-horizon reasoning, where a stable model you can depend on all year beats a brilliant one with a 45-day fuse. But that job is narrow, and it is not the job Argon was sold for four weeks ago.
Buy Hydrogen if your work is everyday work — in the app, in Search or through the API. Keep Argon instead if you run the hardest, longest-horizon problems, or you are building something that must still run next year.
The verdict is final.
How we test
Both sides of this case were weighed on the same named criteria, on the evidence presented in the video. Neither maker was told the result before publication, and neither paid for placement. Where a figure comes from the maker or an independent benchmark, the video names the source on screen. If a product changes materially after the verdict date, the case may be reheard — the original verdict stays on the record.
No link on this page is a live affiliate link — the product buttons are placeholders, and The Tech Jury is not enrolled in any affiliate program yet. When that changes, this note will say so. Commissions will never influence a verdict — see the full affiliate disclosure.